In group theory, we say that a group $(G, \cdot)$ is *abelian* if (and only if) $a \cdot b = b \cdot a$ for all $a, b \in G$.

Abelian groups have certain properties that are generally (that is in the mathematical sense – meaning always) true, so if we know that a group we are dealing with is abelian, we can instantly deduce a variety of things about the group and how it behaves.

Once we know a group is abelian, we can make some useful deductions. Does it work the other way around? Are there truths that will allow us to conclude that a group is abelian?

For what statements are both of these true? What statements imply, and are implied by, the fact that a group is abelian? Essentially, we are asking:

From here onwards we’ll use juxtaposition (like $ab$) rather than an explicit symbol (like $a \cdot b$) to indicate the group operation acting on elements $a$ and $b$.

As an example, take $$(xy)^2 = x^2 y^2 \;\forall x, y \in G$$ Clearly, if G is abelian this is true. Why? Because $$(xy)^2 = (xy)(xy) = x(yx)y = x(xy)y = (xx)(yy) = x^2 y^2$$ using the fact that the group operation is associative and $G$ is abelian.

However, if we write out our first condition slightly differently

$$xyxy = xxyy$$

and then apply the ‘cancellation property’ of groups (cancelling the leftmost $x$ and the rightmost $y$), we end up with

$$yx = xy$$

Succinctly, we have proven

$$(xy)^2 = x^2 y^2 \iff xy = yx$$

for arbitrary elements $x,y$ of a group $G$. Since the elements are arbitrary, we have proven that $G$ is abelian if and only if our original condition is true.

In fact, we might as well *define* a group to be abelian if it satisfies this property. It may seem strange, but this doesn’t change anything about the mathematics at all. Which definition of the long (and in some sense infinite) list of equivalent definitions we happen to choose to be ‘the definition’ is an entirely human distinction. We can take whichever one we like, and the others are then just consequences of this definition (theorems in our theory).

How about another example? Define the direct product of groups $(G, \circ_{G})$ and $(H, \circ_{H})$, denoted $G \oplus H$, to be the cartesian product $G \times H = \{ (g,h) : g \in G, h \in H \}$ with the group operation $\circ$ defined such that $(g_1, h_1) \circ (g_2, h_2) = (g_1 \circ_{G} g_2, h_1 \circ_{H} h_2)$.

Clearly, the direct product of some number of cyclic groups is abelian, since the cyclic groups themselves are abelian, and the componentwise multiplication of the direct product reduces abelianness in the product to abelianness in each participating group.

It is a much deeper fact that the converse is true too: every (finitely generated) abelian group, say $G$, is isomorphic to the direct product of some number of cyclic groups: this is the so-called Fundamental Theorem:

$$G \cong \bigoplus_{i=1}^{n} \mathbb{Z}_{k_i}$$

where $k_1, k_2, \dots, k_n$ are prime powers.

Again, we might as well define an abelian group to be one that has this form, and then the fact that an abelian group’s elements all commute with each other is just another provable theorem.

I think this subtle and perhaps surprising notion of equivalence is rather interesting. It is conceptually easy to prove that two statements are imply each other: just assume one and prove the other, and then repeat the other way around. But to state that the two statements are in fact perfectly equivalent—there exists no universe in which one of these statements is true and the other false—seems like a much stronger thing. And yet it isn’t.

What other interesting equivalences (or alternative definitions) are there in mathematics?

Well, for example: the definition of a prime number.

Most people, if asked, will probably state that a number is prime if and only if it has no factors other than itself and $1$. This seems reasonable, and indeed it is the original motivating definition. However, we can also say that a number $n$ is prime if and only if whenever $n$ divides $ab$, it divides $a$ or $b$ (or both). The first implication (that this is true if $n$ is prime) is a classical theorem called Euclid’s lemma, but in fact the converse is true too and so the statements are equivalent. We might as well define prime numbers this way.

However, something interesting happens when we move from the integers to something more general. In a general ring, these apparently equivalent definitions separate into two distinct notions called ‘prime’ and ‘irreducible’. It just so happens that in the integers (and in general, in a certain class of rings called GCD domains) they coincide.

Another famous example of an interesting equivalence is of course due to the French mathematican Augustin-Louis Cauchy.

The standard definition of convergence of a real sequence is the following:

A sequence $(a_n): \mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{R}$ is said to *converge* (to $L \in \mathbb{R}$) if for all $\epsilon > 0$ there exists an $N \in \mathbb{N}$ such that for all $n > N$ we have $\lvert a_n – L \rvert < \epsilon$.

In words, it is saying that a sequence converges if and only if we can make the value of the sequence arbitrarily close (as close as we like) to the limit point $L$ by moving sufficiently far along the sequence towards infinity.

There are some functions that satisfy this definition for some (unique!) value of $L$, and some that don’t for any. Another similar but subtly different property a function might have is the following:

A sequence $(a_n): \mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{R}$ is said to be *Cauchy* if for all $\epsilon > 0$ there exists an $N \in \mathbb{N}$ such that for all $n, m > N$ we have $\lvert a_n – a_m \rvert < \epsilon$.

This one is saying, in words, that a sequence is Cauchy if and only if the terms in the sequence can be made arbitrarily close to each other by moving sufficiently far along the sequence.

As you may have suspected, these two properties turn out to imply each other: convergent sequences are Cauchy, and Cauchy sequences converge. The first implication is the easier one to prove, but both are true and therefore the two properties are equivalent. They are both perfectly good characterisations of convergence. This is particularly convenient since they contain an important conceptual difference: the second definition makes no mention of a limit, so we can prove convergence to some limit even when we don’t know what that limit actually is. Having these kind of equivalences is actually quite powerful!

So, what is the meaning of all of this? The question is perhaps not a mathematical one, and even then I’m not exactly sure of the answer.

My impression is this: definitions are less important than often assumed; it is the underlying properties of mathematical objects that are fundamental. Definitions are just a human way of putting an abstract concept into one-to-one correspondence with a more concrete ‘testable’ truth.

There are some sequences that are Cauchy, and some sequences that converge. In fact, we are talking about the same set of sequences that all have some ‘underlying property’ in common, but as humans we like to anchor this property to things we can more readily pin down in symbols—even if we end up doing so from two quite different angles.

Your evidence discombobulates me 🙁

Great V I should certainly pronounce, impressed with your website. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs and related info ended up being truly easy to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it in the least. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, web site theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Nice task..

Hi my family member! I wish to say that this post is awesome, nice written and come with almost all vital infos. I would like to peer more posts like this .

YOU NEED QUALITY VISITORS for your: xanderlewis.co.uk

My name is Nadine Kittredge, and I’m a Web Traffic Specialist. I can get:

– visitors from search engines

– visitors from social media

– visitors from any country you want

– very low bounce rate & long visit duration

CLAIM YOUR 24 HOURS FREE TEST => https://bit.ly/3nnmM4I

learn to win money

thank you your welcome

thank you song

thank you thank to you

thank you jesus

thank you hand wash

you think bratz lyrics

paper writing service

general car insurance quote

generic zestril

buy zofran online uk

allianz life insurance

great-west life insurance

female viagra in india online

digoxin 250

you think video

can you buy plaquenil in mexico

over the counter female viagra pill

crestor 10 pill

auto insurance online quotes

over the counter robaxin

over the counter sildenafil

100 financing mortgage calculator

help writing a personal statement

best pharmacy buy tadalafil

buy amoxicillin 875 mg

can i buy valtrex online

hr dissertation

how to thank you in italian

fax payday loan

amitriptyline 10mg tablets

order allegra

you think this is funny

get car insurance online

minocycline 50mg coupon

zestoretic 10 12.5 mg

silagra online

best life insurance

where to order cialis in canada

bad credit payday

covering letter help

buy ponstel

viagra best buy coupon

affordable life insurance

generic daily cialis online

lipitor 20mg price australia

you think he

instant payday loan

viagra tabs

how much is albuterol in canada

midland mortgage company

generic dapoxetine uk

where can i buy viagra in south africa

silagra

Thanks so much for the post.Really thank you! Great.cialis 5 mg funziona

propiedades cialis 5 mg

discreet mailed online viagra

clarinex d backorder skype Vag

isoptin 20 mg

yasmin uk

you think video

dapoxetine buy us

diarex tab price

nizoral pastillas

http://www.propeciaforless.com

sildenafil 20mg online prescription

As I web site possessor I believe the content matter here is rattling excellent , appreciate it for your efforts. You should keep it up forever! Best of luck.

london life insurance

allegra otc coupon

viagra us

tegretol 400 mg tab

sildenafil citrate 90mg

super viagra

what is cialis mg skype Vag

fincar 5mg price

write me an essay

write my dissertation

viagra 100 mg for sale

flomax tablets in india

thanks vs thank you

micardis 40 mg price in india

buy viagra usa

what is the name of the viagra alternative can you take viagra with high blood pressure how much does viagra sell for on the street

I’ll right away snatch your rss feed as I can’t to find your e-mail subscription link or newsletter service.

Do you have any? Kindly permit me recognize so that I may subscribe.

Thanks.

over the counter viagra

where to buy coreg

dapoxetine buy online canada

Greetings from Idaho! I’m bored to death at work so I decided to browse your

blog on my iphone during lunch break. I enjoy the information you present

here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m surprised at how fast

your blog loaded on my mobile .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G ..

Anyhow, amazing site!

va loan

proscar cost in us

lanoxin medication

essay writer help

my prudential life insurance policy

loan without bank account

what is the difference between male and female viagra which is better cialis or viagra? best way to get viagra online how many men take viagra what works better cialis or viagra want to buy viagra an painpills online from canadian pharmacy

online algebra help

I enjoy whst yoou guyus end tto bbe upp too. Suchh clewver woork andd reporting!

Keeep upp the great woirks guyhs I’ve included yoou gguys too mmy peersonal blogroll.

yasmin tablet india

us floxin over the counter

I will immediately grasp your rss feed as I can’t to find your email subscription hyperlink

or newsletter service. Do you’ve any? Please permit me know so that I may just subscribe.

Thanks.

can you buy viagra in mexico

buy malegra from india

I am sure this piece of writing has touched all the internet users,

its really really nice post on building up new web site.

writing essays for money – buy term papers online online essay writer

buy lasix without prescription

472619 209016Some times its a pain in the ass to read what blog owners wrote but this site is really user pleasant! . 998385

online payday loan instant approval

credit union auto loan rates

cheap paper writing – help me write a research paper help with term paper

auto insurance quotes comparison

purchase viagra over the counter

buy diclofenac 50mg

viagra generic online in america

can you buy sildenafil citrate skype Vag

Greetings! Very helpful advice within this article!

It’s the little changes that produce the most significant changes.

Many thanks for sharing!

car insurance companies in michigan

hydroxychloroquine sulfate nz

These are genuinely impressive ideas in concerning blogging.

You have touched some nice points here.

Any way keep up wrinting.

payday advance loans

rapid loans

free adult webcam

personal loan review

emergency health insurance anxiety health risks

kamagra now

buy kamagra oral jelly

I am sure this article has touched all the internet users,

its really really nice paragraph on building

up new webpage.

doxazosin 2mg

Likes on Instagram can improve your brand’s engagement numbers. When you buy Instagram likes you get more engagement on your profile which means more reputation.

acyclovir 1000 mg

I am sure this paragraph has touched all the internet people,

its really really fastidious post on building up new website.

a thesis statement

online sildenafil

The other day, while I was at work, my cousin stole my iphone and tested to see if

it can survive a thirty foot drop, just so she can be a

youtube sensation. My iPad is now destroyed and she has

83 views. I know this is totally off topic but I had to share it with someone!

avalide best price

hydroxychloroquine tablets buy online

prescription drugs online without doctor https://canadaedgeneric.com/ buy generic drugs online

essay writing on friendship

I see something really special in this website.

coreg for anxiety

essay writing linking words

best loans for bad credit

flomax no prescription

Ahaa, its pleasant dialogue on the topic of this paragraph here at this webpage,

I have read all that, so now me also commenting at this place.

viagra sales

compare and contrast writing

insurance quotes online comparison

zestoretic 10 12.5 mg

malegra dxt without prescription

where can i buy viagra over the counter in sydney

viagra in the water

best discount viagra skype Vag

college essay prepscholar

Or does this only play a role when trying to reformat the drive under Windows?

best auto insurance

vitality health insurance

money online

Way cool! Some very valid points! I appreciate you writing this article plus the

rest of the site is also very good.

dairyland insurance company

cash advance installment loans

where to buy female viagra pill ingredient in cialis what does a viagra look like

cost of stromectol medication

elevex tadalafil 20mg

pink viagra for women

para que sirve magnus sildenafil 50 mg skype Vag

the band is light as many have reviewed.

Likes on Instagram can improve your brand’s engagement numbers. When you buy Instagram likes you get more engagement on your profile which means more reputation.

you get into dental school .

it is a nice going out watch for formal occasions.

Likes on Instagram can improve your brand’s engagement numbers. When you buy Instagram likes you get more engagement on your profile which means more reputation.

insurance plan

pletal 100 mg

naltrexone weight loss medication combination https://naltrexone.mlsmalta.com/

bad credit history

It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is

time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you few interesting things or

tips. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article.

I want to read even more things about it!

american doctors and hydroxychloroquine https://hydroxychloroquine.webbfenix.com/

help with dissertation writing

hydroxychloroquine 4 mg

best health insurance plans for individuals

benevolent

einsurance

zovirax 200mg tablets

clomid prescription price https://clomidweb.com/

cialis compare discount price

I am sure this post has touched all the internet

viewers, its really really nice post on building up new weblog.

modafinil 100 mg tablet

safeway insurance

Greetings! Very useful advice in this particular article!

It’s the little changes that make the biggest changes.

Thanks for sharing!

sildenafil online purchase india

what is best viagra or cenforce is there an ed treatment better than viagra and fdc approved is 25mg of viagra enough how to get viagra by mail viagra dosage for 70 year old where can you find otc viagra or cialis

viagra pills online uk

causes of ed https://canadaedgeneric.com/ buy generic drugs cheap

generic levitra us

ed drug prices https://canadaedgeneric.com/ buy generic drugs online

how to use vidalista 5mg https://vidalista.mlsmalta.com/

best canadian pharmacy online https://canadaedgeneric.com/ buy generic drugs from canada medications

ed clinic https://canadaedgeneric.com/ canadian pharmacy

sildenafil generic sildenafil pharmacy

prescription drugs canada buy online https://canadaedgeneric.com/ buy generic drugs cheap

auto insurance comparison chart

whole life insurance policies

the effects of suhagra https://suhagra.buszcentrum.com/

nolvadex 20mg price in india https://tamoxifen.mrdgeography.com/

ed in young men https://canadaedgeneric.com/ drugs from india

online pharmacy

daily cialis price http://www.lm360.us/

erectile dysfunction drug https://canadaedgeneric.com/ buy generic drugs online from india

ashwagandha medicine price

personal loans for bad credit payday loans no credit check instant approval

dapoxetine 60 mg in usa https://dapoxetine.bee-rich.com/

100mg viagra without a doctor prescription https://canadaedgeneric.com/ buy generic drugs

I needed to thank you for this wonderful read!! I certainly loved every little

bit of it. I have got you bookmarked to check out

new stuff you

what parasites does ivermectin kill in humans https://ivermectin.webbfenix.com/

YOU NEED QUALITY VISITORS FOR YOUR: xanderlewis.co.uk

WE PROVIDE ORGANIC VISITORS BY KEYWORD FROM SEARCH ENGINES OR SOCIAL MEDIA

YOU GET HIGH-QUALITY VISITORS

– visitors from search engines

– visitors from social media

– visitors from any country you want

CLAIM YOUR 24 HOURS FREE TEST => https://bit.ly/2HQZggh

male dysfunction treatment https://canadaedgeneric.com/ canadian pharmacy

livejasmin mature

cash advances

YOU NEED QUALITY VISITORS FOR YOUR: xanderlewis.co.uk

WE PROVIDE ORGANIC VISITORS BY KEYWORD FROM SEARCH ENGINES OR SOCIAL MEDIA

YOU GET HIGH-QUALITY VISITORS

– visitors from search engines

– visitors from social media

– visitors from any country you want

CLAIM YOUR 24 HOURS FREE TEST => https://bit.ly/2HQZggh

sinequan 100 mg

online canadian pharmacy https://canadaedgeneric.com/ best place to buy generic drugs

funeral insurance plans

cialis soft tabs uk

buy erectafil 20

online canadian pharmacy https://canadaedgeneric.com/ buy generic drugs online

teen cam

live naked